Advertising


News

Antipsychotic use in aged care ‘not ideal’


Chelsea Heaney


23/07/2024 4:12:46 PM

New data shows antipsychotic prescriptions significantly outweigh diagnoses, a situation unlikely to change without greater staffing support.

A doctor handing medications to an elderly patient
Around 63,183 people in aged care are on nine or more medications.

Aged care patients are being treated with antipsychotics at a rate that is at least double the level of psychosis diagnoses, according to new data.
 
The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW) has released its latest Residential Aged Care Quality Indicators – January to March 2024 data, revealing that 18% of patients use antipsychotic medication, while the rate of antipsychotic use with a psychotic diagnosis is just 9%.
 
Separately, the latest results from the AIHW Mental Health in Aged Care report show 4.1% of people aged 65 years and over had a psychotic disorder recorded on their aged care assessment.
 
Professor Dimity Pond, a GP with a special interest in aged care, said ‘the use of antipsychotics is far from optimal’.
 
Professor Pond says that much of the prescribing of antipsychotics can be attributed to dementia, which is not classified as a psychosis.
 
‘There’s a good reason for it, but it’s not ideal,’ she told newsGP.
 
She says medication is often used in place of human contact that could sooth agitated patients.
 
‘I would point the finger at the fact that the alternative for agitation, and crying, and so on in dementia is quite concentrated on nursing care,’ she said.
 
‘There’s not enough staff, and there aren’t enough staff because these facilities can’t afford it, and that’s because the Government limits how much money goes per person.
 
‘That doesn’t leave enough money to pay for a large number of staff to look after people.’
 
Professor Pond has patients herself that she has had to give antipsychotics as the logistics of their care situation means that they cannot get the support they need in person.
 
‘This patient was crying at night and missing her husband when she first moved in, and she was fine if the nurse would sit with her for five minutes at night, and she would settle,’ she said.
 
‘But the thing is, there’s only one nurse on in a ward of more than 30 people, and she couldn’t spend five minutes every hour with my patient.’
 
Polypharmacy in aged care is also at 34.6%, with 63,183 people on nine or more medications.
 
But people with dementia, which Professor Pond says is more than 50% of patients, often have multiple comorbidity issues.
 
‘People with dementia have an average of five other chronic diseases, and all of those might require medications,’ she said.
 
‘We’re supposed to deprescribe as a person gets older, where we look at what they’re on, and we think about their life expectancy, and we reduce their medications, but it’s a very challenging thing to do.
 
‘You know that you’re gradually removing supports for that person’s physical health, and you need to discuss it with the relatives and so on, so there’s a time, resource, funding and ethical issues around all of that.’
 
Professor Pond ties these issues back to a lack of support and remuneration for GPs putting in excessive hours of unpaid work.
 
‘There’s an awful lot of discussions needed that we can’t charge for,’ she said.
 
‘The amount of work that you must put in to be a GP in residential aged care, and the amount of distress around it, the difficult issues and the amount of time you have to spend on unpaid parts of that work, the remuneration is not sufficient.
 
‘I think it’s unsustainable, unless we can find some other model or more money.’
 
Log in below to join the conversation.


aged care antidepressants depression elder abuse medication mental health overprescribed psychosis psychotherapy


newsGP weekly poll Which of the following areas are you more likely to discuss during a routine consultation?
 
20%
 
0%
 
30%
 
50%
Related



newsGP weekly poll Which of the following areas are you more likely to discuss during a routine consultation?

Advertising

Advertising

 

Login to comment

Dr Gerard Phillip Connors   24/07/2024 11:31:27 AM

Totally agree Dimity. I can remember a time when there was adequate staffing and the use of anti psychotics for agitation in dementia was minimal/ non- existent in most cases.
Once staffing levels started to drop the demand for anti psychotics was driven by the staff, not GP’s or relatives


Prof Joachim Peter Sturmberg   24/07/2024 12:00:43 PM

Most things in nursing home care are 'not ideal'. They are all the outcomes of the systemic failings within the system (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jep.13961) which needs a bottom-up redesign (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jep.13987). There is a real danger of perpetuating and entrenching the 'not ideal' state by focusing on single issues only - like the prescribing of one drug or another.


Dr Julia Ann Conway   5/08/2024 9:19:53 PM

I would like to know how to handle requests for medication by nursing staff for residents who repeatedly violently attack them or other residents, shout loudly all night keeping others awake and continue all day, often with swearing and racist remarks or even repeatedly touching other residents, throwing things,taking other residents belongings or trying to get into bed with them and exhaustive prolonged repetitive overactivity. These things are extremely frequent occurrences in dementia facilities. Sitting with a resident for 5 minutes will usually be ineffective and it has been clear to me that staff and family members have usually tried a whole range of distractive techniques before asking a doctor to medicate.
Nobody wants to prescribe these medications but their continued use seems to suggest that there are no easy answers. I doubt they are given by GPs for loneliness.