Advertising


News

GPs in training pay discrepancies laid bare


Michelle Wisbey


30/01/2025 5:13:01 PM

New data shows 55% of GPs in training earn less money than in their last year in a pre-vocational hospital position – a trend one GP expert labelled a ‘huge concern’.

Blurred hospital ward.
Just 23% of the 1274 respondents say they earn more than their last year working in a pre-vocational hospital position.

More than half (55%) of general practice registrars are earning less money in GP training than in their last year working in a pre-vocational hospital position, according to a new survey.
 
The annual National report on the 2024 National Registrar Survey, released on Wednesday, has laid bare the pay disparities faced by GPs in training.
 
Positively, the survey revealed that in terms of registrars’ satisfaction with their training provider, including the RACGP, 89% were satisfied with the quality of overall training and education experience, and 88% were satisfied with the quality of training advice and the feedback on their training progress.
 
It found 86% were satisfied with the workshops and webinars provided, 87% were satisfied with the training and education resources available, 85% were satisfied with the medical educator facilitated peer learning provided, and 85% were satisfied with the support to meet their training provider’s training requirements.
 
Additionally, when registrars were asked to reflect on their experience with their training facility, 91% were satisfied with the overall training and education experience and 92% were satisfied with the supervisor’s support.
 
However, answering a new set of questions introduced in 2024, just 23% of the 1274 respondents say they earn more than their last year working in a pre-vocational hospital position.
 
This also varies substantially between the states and territories.
 
More than half of registrars in the Northern Territory were earning more than in their last year of pre-vocational hospital training (52%), but it was 12% in Victoria, 22% in New South Wales, 29% in South Australia, and 32% in Queensland.
 
‘This may be due to registrars in the Northern Territory receiving higher levels of additional support payments or other benefits than registrars from most other states and territories,’ the research said.
 
‘Overall, 44% of registrars reported receiving additional support payments or benefits in semester one, 2024, but a much higher proportion of registrars training in the Northern Territory (71%) received additional support.’
 
RACGP GPs in Training Chair Dr Bec Loveridge told newsGP this was further proof of what general practice registrars already know – that those who leave the hospital system to start GP training ‘almost universally take a pay cut’.
 
She said that, on the ground, this is leaving junior doctors to make tough decisions about their future careers.
 
‘We hear from medical students and junior doctors who aren’t yet in training all the time that their primary concern is related to finances,’ Dr Loveridge said.
 
‘They like the idea of general practice, it’s the work that they want to do, but everyone’s got other things to consider when it comes to making a career choice and it isn’t always up to what you want to do.
 
‘Sometimes you have to make choices that are the right thing for your family or for your personal goals in life, so we know from speaking to those who aren’t yet in training, that it is a huge concern for them, and this data backs up what we already knew.’
 
The survey also found that 19% worked as a hospital locum, and 53% said their total pre-tax earnings were below $60,000 in semester one of 2024.
 
Additionally, 43% of respondents said they did not receive any additional payments and 30% received less than $5000 in additional payments.
 
The RACGP has long been calling for greater pay parity for those future GPs leaving the hospital system.
 
Ahead of last year’s Federal Budget, one of the college’s main advocacy calls was for registrars to be offered the same leave entitlements as their hospital counterparts.
 
Dr Loveridge said making up that gap would ‘make a huge difference’.
 
‘There’s a barrier in the fact that when you leave the hospital, you lose access to paid parental leave and paid study leave, as well as any long service entitlements,’ she said.
 
‘People want to do general practice when it works for their life, and from speaking on behalf of the GPs in Training faculty, it’s something that we hear every single time we get any inquiry from any member.
 
‘We’re very united in our desire to have this discrepancy when you leave the hospital addressed, so that it’s fair and not an artificial barrier for building the future GP workforce of Australia.’
 
Log in below to join the conversation.


Federal Budget GPs in training medical students rural health workforce


newsGP weekly poll Health practitioners found guilty of sexual misconduct will soon have the finding permanently recorded on their public register record. Do you support this change?
 
59%
 
26%
 
13%
Related




newsGP weekly poll Health practitioners found guilty of sexual misconduct will soon have the finding permanently recorded on their public register record. Do you support this change?

Advertising

Advertising

 

Login to comment

Dr Peter Thomas Kenny   31/01/2025 7:01:21 AM

This is the heart of the problem, GP work is poorly remunerated. It’s not just a problem in the first year but every year thereafter. The solution is obvious and simple, increase GP remuneration and there will be no shortage of young doctors wanting to make a career in General Practice.


xxx   31/01/2025 8:54:08 AM

I earn in 1 day doing a locum at my local hospital- what I earn in 1 week in general practice. The figure speaks for itself.


Dr Joshua Hoey   31/01/2025 9:54:25 AM

New research to point out an issue that’s been ongoing and known about for years. The registrar survey is great, but let’s do something about it. If primary care is important, pay trainees the same as their hospital colleagues. Increased pay would attract more applicants to AGPT and general practice training programs, alleviating the GP shortage. It’s pretty simple.


Dr Muhammad Hafizei Muhammad Nasir   31/01/2025 9:55:30 AM

Money can’t buy happiness, until you can’t pay your mortgage. The demand of exam and life was not the best experience for me; I had to catch up with family afterwards and revelation day was when I was negative in cashflow! Took me 2-3x next pays (about 6 weeks) to recoup but the angst of it was quite testing. All done now. Point to note is, if a registrar could not proceed to fellowship, with this financial impact, well in my case if I failed the exams, the extreme of that was bancruptcy (perhaps the motivation, ha!)


Dr David Lap Yan Lee   31/01/2025 10:28:36 AM

First world problem. Money can fix everything. I did locum on W/E to survive my registrar years. It is actually an incentive to complete the training ASAP. Once you finish exam you instantly triple your income >200k (40*4*8*5*50*0.7) is great and if you want a pay rise just charge whatever you want.


Anonymous   31/01/2025 11:01:29 AM

Exactly my thoughts Peter, why not just increase the rebates appropriately and address this problem along with the many others currently faced by GPs ie gaps/bulk billing rates, clinic closures etc. Instead the college advocates for Band-Aid fixes like government grants for registrars which do help but aren’t going to address the root cause.


ABC   31/01/2025 1:52:49 PM

Dr Lee’s comment and attitude perfectly encapsulates why rebates have been frozen for so long. Relying on locum shifts to survive registrar years is absolutely absurd. The government will never properly increase GP remuneration if there’s no pressure on them to do so. Just look at what’s happening in nsw, the government trying to guilt psychiatrists back to work instead of paying them appropriately.


Dr Abdul Ahad Khan   31/01/2025 4:11:50 PM

Nurses go on Strikes, as they have the Back-up of the Nurses Federation & the Govt. of the day caves in !

Specialists go on Strike, because they have the Back-up of the A.M.A. & the Gov

TALKFESTS with the Parliamentarians has not worked for years & years & never will.

RACGP needs to Co-ordinate a Nation-wide ONE - DAY STETHOSCOPE -DOWN STRIKE , with full Media Coverage & back up the GP Registrars & the Slaving GPs at the Coal-face.
RACGP needs to show their loyalty towards GPs for a change - enough of lying in bed with the Government of the day will 100% cave in.

DR. AHAD KHAN


Dr Ginita Oberoi   3/02/2025 1:21:28 PM

It seems that how this question was worded in the survey does not take into account what hours the registrar is working. Many registrars become part time when they enter GP training after working full time in the hospital. After all, work life balance is the reason some GP registrars join the program. Additionally GP registrars are probably doing less after hours work (with penalty rates) than in their hospital life. This figure might not be as dramatic as it seems on face value.

However that doesn’t take away from the fact that general practice as a whole is underfunded, especially when coupled with the how cost effective preventive and community healthcare is to the system. I wish that ‘government invests millions in general practice to prevent illness’ was as sexy of a headline as ‘government invests millions to build new fancy hospital’