Advertising


News

‘I can’t do this’: Practice closures continue


Michelle Wisbey


23/08/2024 11:20:28 AM

Another general practice has added its name to an alarmingly long list of clinics shutting up shop, as the owners warn ‘the situation is not improving’.

Dr Liz Chappel.
Dr Liz Chappel at the Apple Tree Medical Cairns clinic.

‘It was very hard to make the decision and we agonised for a couple of weeks, but once we made the decision, it was a sense of relief.’
 
That is Dr Liz Chappel, a practice owner of 20 years who, this week, announced the closure of her Cairns clinic, Apple Tree Medical.
 
‘I just went, I can’t do this,’ she told newsGP.
 
‘I went to the supermarket the other day, and we had $30 to our name, and after 40 years of working full time, I was a bit pissed off about that.’
 
Dr Chappel, who owns two clinics in Far North Queensland, has now begun moving all her patients and staff to her second centre, which will remain open.
 
Already, there has been an outpouring of support for Dr Chappel and her staff, after she announced the closure, which will take place on 30 August.
 
‘I couldn’t think of a better GP to have cared for my family over those years,’ one patient said.
 
‘I have witnessed you both pour your blood, sweat and tears into your Cairns practice. It has been inspiring to watch.’
 
In June, Dr Chappel spoke out after constant GP vacancies forced her to cut the clinic’s opening hours to just three days a week.
 
Then, she described the decision as ‘dire and unsustainable’, and now, just months later, she said that unfortunate prediction has come true.
 
‘I just got to the point where I could not do it anymore, and there’s a massive amount of guilt that goes along with that,’ Dr Chappel said.
 
‘People have been overwhelmingly beautiful, and I’ve received an awful lot of support and personal messages from team members, colleagues, and patients.
 
‘The situation is not improving, and I can’t see how it is quickly going to improve because the job is so tough.’
 
And she is not alone.
 
Practices across Australia, in every state and territory, are continuing to close, as the combined pressures of owning a business and operating in the current healthcare environment weigh on owners.
 
Dr Chappel said if this sad trend is ever to be reversed, significant changes are needed to help GPs make their practices, and livelihoods, more sustainable.
 
‘The registrars seem to get the qualifications, and then either go and have babies because they’ve been working for so long, or they go into a sub-specialty because it pays very well, or they work as locums,’ she said.
 
‘And I think if I were them, I’d do it too.
 
‘We’re trying very hard to recruit, we’re trying to recruit from overseas but it’s massively cumbersome.’
 
Earlier this month, new Federal Government modelling revealed the scope of the GP shortage engulfing Australia.
 
Nationally, there is currently a shortage of 2466 full-time equivalent GPs, which is predicted to grow to 5560 by 2033, and up to 8908 in 2048.
 
This prediction comes as, in the next 40 years, the number of Australians aged 65 and above is expected to more than double, the number aged 85 and above will more than triple, and the number of centenarians is expected to increase six-fold.
 
Creating a scenario where patients are older, sicker, and with more chronic conditions, at a time when GPs are in short supply.
 
‘How do I see the future of general practice? I’m a bit pessimistic at the moment,’ Dr Chappel said.
 
The RACGP has recently announced several upped incentive payments in an attempt to remedy the situation and attract new GPs to the regions where they are needed most.
 
But for now, Dr Chappel is looking forward to having just one practice to concentrate her efforts on.
 
‘Now the decision has been made, I’ve got to move forward, and my main focus, my only focus, is to come to work and do my absolute best, because that’s all you can do really, isn’t it?’ she said.
 
Log in below to join the conversation.



general practice funding practice closures


newsGP weekly poll Do you use the GP Psychiatry Support Line?
 
0%
 
100%
 
0%
Related




newsGP weekly poll Do you use the GP Psychiatry Support Line?

Advertising

Advertising


Login to comment

Dr Peter James Strickland   24/08/2024 10:54:13 AM

People have been brain-washed by socialist governments that health care is free. It all started with Medibank Mk1, and the signs were there then --- minimal remuneration for GPs, and it has continued for the last 50 odd years. The basic Item 23 rebate should now be around $80. Just imagine the govt. giving only that amount ($80) for a legal option or consult --they would laughed at! Medicare is insurance only for patients, and all patients should pay something for their GP consults above the Medicare payment, and have that payment as a tax deduction. That would mean GP practice survival now and into the future.


Dr John Henry Jarzynski   24/08/2024 11:07:59 AM

Doctors! Come and join us at Ballina West Medical Centre : 70% and NO ON-CALL. Monday to Friday, NO week-ends. Beautiful!!


Dr Joanna Holland   24/08/2024 11:16:56 AM

If the government is serious about increasing GP numbers from an existing workforce disenchanted by the public system, but needing to stay in place due to family commitments, they might consider funding second year FSP trainees. FSP training costs a trainee $20,000 the first year, $16,000 second year. As they say in return to work plans, you need to lower the barriers...


Dr Naaman Graham Malouf   24/08/2024 12:58:47 PM

After 50 years of GP I have retired One of the main reasons is no longer is there a contract between Patient and Practitioner it has become a contract between Patient and The Government with the Practitioner being merely the conduit who survives wholly and solely at the "largess" of political will of ther Government of the day. Yes finances suffer but equally as important professional satisfaction suffers as well because you can't survive on patient gratitude. That won't even buy you a jar of Vegemite. I have been around long enough to see both sides of this discussion and I have seen one side of the discussion work. The current situation is as a result of the other side. I miss my profession but would not go back while the current situation exists. I wonder if any of our "leaders" have had enough years ofpractice to see the alternate point of view?


Dr Henry Beirne Chevallier Bryan   24/08/2024 2:04:44 PM

This is probably the most important article I have read this year. When will the people of Australia realise that they are losing general practice, the corner stone of medical practice for most Australians. People blame the policies of successive governments but it is the people who refuse to accept that they are responsible for demise of their local general medical practice. In my area it costs more to have a haircut and a beard trim than patients pay their GP. Universities only accept the brightest minds to be medical students; smart students see where there is reward for their hard work and choose to specialise.
This article records that sadness I and I suspect many of you feel for the profession I have devoted my life to for 45 years like the heroines and heroes of Cairns who were brave enough to describe the real situation in General Practice. There is not enough money and not enough GPs.
Good luck Australia you have brought this in yourself.


Dr Tan Quoc Le Tran   24/08/2024 2:53:56 PM

same here we are closed on Saturday & cut hours during the week as bulk billing rebates is not catching with inflation . I am considered private billing for non concession card holder . Bulk Billing is dead


Dr Bethany Reynolds   27/08/2024 4:03:26 PM

It's so confusing to me that the government is measuring bulk billing rates - the more they continue to sell the population that that is a good goal without making the rebate sustainable, the more they are setting everyone up for failure. They are idiots if they think GPs and clinics can afford to continue with bulk billing and GPs altruism alone. Unless they make changes, incentivise/reward the difficult work (rural, long complex, mental health), and normalising patients paying for aspects of their care it is unsustainable.


Dr Rifaat Roshdy Salama Girgis   28/08/2024 3:44:09 AM

Also waiting for the compulsory health check at 70 years of age for all older experienced GP’s who are keeping primary health care afloat currently.
Many of us GP’s will take the easy way out as we had enough of this nonsense. Who is going to suffer?
Only the patients.


Dr Maureen Anne Howard   31/08/2024 11:17:01 AM

I feel we are going to lose our senior and most experienced GPs in the next few years. I have been a GP since 1978, starting my own practice at age 26. I realise now I would've been much better off financially working for other GPs. I couldn't afford many holidays or time off, and, like most GPs, would work when sick etc. I love general practice, especially dealing with veterans and very complex patients, but now work very short hours in a great practice. I wish Dr Chappel success, and I hope she is telling her patients why she is closing her practice. You need a holiday, Dr Chappel!


Dr Abdul Ahad Khan   31/08/2024 5:14:41 PM

All TALK & ZERO ACTION by the RACGP, has resulted in the Pathetic state facing GPs & GP Practices are closing on a Regular frequency.

It is time for the RACGP to commence Industrial Action & simultaneously rallying the Support of the Populace via TV / RADIO / NEWSPAPERS / FACEBOOK,etc.

The Govt. cares a damn about GPs ,who constitute less than 1% of our Populace.
CRIES from the other 99% of our Populace will bring the Govt. on its Knees & crawling to a Negotiating Table - it is high time the RACGP shows some Muscle Power.

The RACGP is a Toothless Tiger & has Sold us Coal-face GPs off - to the Cheapest Bidder - the Government in Power !!!

with continued disappointment in the RACGP,
DR. AHAD KHAN


Dr Abdul Ahad Khan   1/09/2024 5:13:56 PM

All TALK & ZERO ACTION by the RACGP, has resulted in the Pathetic state facing GPs today.
GP Practices are closing on a Regular frequency.

It is time for the RACGP to commence Industrial Action & simultaneously rallying the Support of the Populace via TV / RADIO / NEWSPAPERS / FACEBOOK,etc.

The Govt. cares a damn about GPs ,who constitute less than 1% of our Populace.
CRIES from the other 99% of our Populace will bring the Govt. on its Knees & crawling to a Negotiating Table - it is high time the RACGP shows some Muscle Power.

The Govt. cares a damn about these TALKFESTS / TALK GROUPS & about the RACGP - the Toothless Tiger.
with continued disappointment in the RACGP,
DR. AHAD KHAN